Board of Directors
- Kelly Rhinehart — President
- Rodney Kolstee — Vice President
- Maureen Langebartel —Treasurer
- Darlene Barney — Assistant Treasurer
- James Kianos — Secretary
- Kenneth Burnett — Director
- Brian Coffaro — Director
- Tammy McCool — Director
- Tracy Pierce — Director
Supervisory Committee
- Karen Bifaro — Chairperson
- Marsha Butler — Secretary
- Dale Ricker — Vice Chairperson
Administrative Office
- Kelly Haaksma — Manager / CEO
- Lori FitzPatrick — Director of Branch Operations
- Julie Brown — HR Manager
- Traci Spencer — Senior Loan Officer
- Derek DeVlieger — Floating Branch Supervisor
- Amy Stroebel — Financial Operations Coordinator
- Jody Vine — Collections Manager
- Jody Radack — Payment Solutions Specialist
- Cindy Palmer — EFT Processor
- Amber Conklin — Accountant
- Angela Leach — Back Office Administrative Assistant
- Branden Johnson — IT / Security Administrator
- Brittney Quattrone — Design Coordinator / Business Development
Falconer Branch Staff
- Lori FitzPatrick — Director of Branch Operations / Branch Manager
- Tina Morley — Loan Officer
- Ashley Johnson — Loan Officer
- Sarah Overturf — Teller Manager
- Kayla Bergman — Member Service Representative
- Deryck Brown — Member Service Representative
- Naomi Engstrom — Member Service Representative
- Alyssa Marucci — Member Service Representative
Jamestown Branch Staff
- Naomi Smith — Jamestown Branch Coordinator
- Leandra Sample — Senior Member Service Representative (New Account Rep/Loan Processor)
Dunkirk Branch Staff
- Brandi Letersky — Branch Manager
- Valerie Emmick — Assistant Branch Manager / Loan Officer
- Vanessa Organ — Member Service Representative
- Yadhielis Vazquez Castro — Member Service Representative
- Anthony Gonzalez — Member Service Representative
Mayville Branch Staff
- Heather Harley — Branch Manager / Loan Officer
- LeighAnn VanArsdale — Member Service Representative
- Victoria Wells — Member Service Representative
- Kristina Calhoun — Part-time Member Service Representative